Financial Instruments Business Operator: Director-General of the Kanto Local Finance Bureau (FIBO) No. 2176Real Estate Brokerage Business: Governor of Tokyo (2) No. 102550

News

SEC Chairman outlines a "token taxonomy" for crypto assets

2025-11-12

In a November 12 speech at the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, SEC Chairman Paul Atkins set out a token taxonomy as the next phase of "Project Crypto." Under this approach, digital commodities (network tokens), digital collectibles and digital tools are not securities, while tokenized securities remain securities.

Overview

On November 12, 2025, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chairman Paul Atkins delivered a speech at the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia titled "The SEC's Approach to Digital Assets: Inside 'Project Crypto.'" As the next phase of the SEC's Project Crypto initiative, he outlined a token taxonomy for crypto assets. The Chairman noted that the remarks reflected his own views and not necessarily those of the Commission.

Background

In the United States, the lack of clear criteria for determining whether a crypto asset is a security has long been seen as a problem. The analysis rests on the Howey test, derived from a U.S. Supreme Court decision: an investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits from the essential managerial efforts of others constitutes an "investment contract" and therefore a security. Through Project Crypto, Chairman Atkins has been working to clarify the rules for crypto assets, while Congress has been considering legislation on crypto market structure.

Key Points

CategoryDescriptionSecurity?
Digital commodities (network tokens)Value derives from the operation of a "functional" and "decentralized" crypto systemNot a security
Digital collectiblesItems designed to be collected or used, such as art, music, trading cards or in-game itemsNot a security
Digital toolsTokens with practical functions, such as memberships, tickets, credentials, title instruments or identity badgesNot a security
Tokenized securitiesRepresent ownership of an instrument within the statutory definition of a security, maintained on a crypto networkRemain securities
  • The Chairman said most crypto assets are not themselves securities, but may be part of an investment contract where the issuer makes explicit and unambiguous promises.
  • An investment contract can end, for example when the issuer fulfils or fails to fulfil its promises; subsequent trades would not be securities transactions merely because of the token's origin.
  • He referred to a package of offering exemptions ("Regulation Crypto") for crypto assets that are part of or subject to an investment contract.
  • Anti-fraud provisions continue to apply, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) retains anti-fraud and anti-manipulation authority over tokens that are commodities.

The speech also revealed that the Chairman has asked SEC staff to recommend allowing tokens tied to an investment contract to trade not only on SEC-registered venues but also through CFTC-registered intermediaries or state-regulated platforms, while capital formation would remain under SEC oversight. Using the citrus grove at the center of the Howey case as an analogy, he noted that the land is not a security today, illustrating his view that an asset once tied to an investment scheme does not remain a security indefinitely. He also praised the work of Acting CFTC Chairman Pham and expressed support for the confirmation of CFTC nominee Mike Selig.

Implications for Markets and Companies

The taxonomy appears to offer issuers and trading platforms a framework for assessing where securities regulation applies. However, it was presented as the Chairman's personal view and is not yet a legally binding rule, which should be kept in mind. For companies engaged in crypto-related business in Japan and Hong Kong, the direction of U.S. policy is likely to be one factor in business design and overseas expansion. Because tokenized securities continue to be treated as securities, their issuance and circulation will presumably still need to comply with existing securities regulation.

Outlook and Schedule

The Chairman said the Commission may consider the token taxonomy and the Regulation Crypto exemptions "in the coming months." He also expressed support for congressional work on market structure legislation and said the SEC would work with the CFTC and banking regulators. The timing and content of any specific rule proposals have not yet been determined.

Comment from TAKARA

Developments in U.S. crypto regulation may influence the international framework for digital asset businesses, including tokenized securities. TAKARA will continue to monitor regulatory developments in the U.S., Hong Kong and Japan and to provide information on related licensing procedures and overseas expansion.

This article provides general information based on published materials and news reports. It is not a solicitation or recommendation of any financial product and does not constitute investment advice.

Back to News

Consultation

Every engagement begins with a conversation.

We welcome enquiries regarding financial licence applications, overseas listing support, M&A advisory, investment advice and real estate. Once we have reviewed your enquiry, a member of our team will be in touch.

Contact Form