News
FSA Publishes Discussion Paper on Reviewing the Crypto-Asset Regulatory Framework
2025-04-10
Japan's Financial Services Agency published a discussion paper titled "Review of Systems Related to Crypto-Assets" and invited comments until May 10. The paper considers, among other things, handling crypto-assets under the framework of the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, and discusses disclosure, measures against unregistered operators and insider-trading rules as ways to balance user protection with innovation.
Overview
On April 10, 2025, Japan's Financial Services Agency (FSA) published a discussion paper titled "Review of Systems Related to Crypto-Assets" and invited public comments until 17:00 on Saturday, May 10. Prepared in line with the FSA's Strategic Priorities for the 2024 program year, the paper reviews the current framework in light of how crypto-assets are actually traded, with the aim of creating an environment that balances user protection and the promotion of innovation. The FSA stated that comments received would be used in further deliberations, including on specific regulatory amendments.
Background
Crypto-assets were brought under a certain level of regulation through the 2019 amendments to the Payment Services Act and the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act (FIEA), but the situation has changed significantly since then. According to the paper, the cumulative number of accounts opened at domestic crypto-asset exchange service providers exceeds 12 million, user deposits exceed JPY 5 trillion, and about 7.3% of people with investment experience hold crypto-assets, a higher share than for FX trading or corporate bonds. In the US, more than 1,200 institutional investors have invested in spot bitcoin ETFs, showing that crypto-assets are increasingly treated as investment targets internationally. At the same time, fraudulent solicitation and solicitation by unregistered operators are widespread, and the FSA receives more than 300 crypto-related complaints and inquiries per month on average.
Key Points
- Basic approach: Issues such as disclosure, investment fraud and fair price formation closely resemble problems the FIEA has traditionally addressed, so using the FIEA's mechanisms and enforcement tools is presented as one option.
- Two categories: The paper proposes examining separately "fundraising/business-activity type" crypto-assets issued to raise funds for projects (Category 1) and all other crypto-assets, including bitcoin, ether and so-called meme coins (Category 2).
- Disclosure: For Category 1, issuers raising funds could be required to disclose and provide information; for Category 2, the exchange service providers handling the assets could be required to provide information.
- Business regulation: Issues include more effective deterrence of unregistered operators and bringing investment management and investment advice relating to crypto-assets within the scope of regulation. For reference, the paper compares penalties for unregistered business: up to three years' imprisonment under the Payment Services Act versus up to five years under the FIEA.
- Market regulation: The paper considers that, at present, there is little need to impose a strict licensing regime equivalent to that for financial instruments exchanges on crypto trading platforms.
- Insider trading: As current law has no direct prohibition, several drafting approaches are compared, including listing material facts specifically, defining them in abstract terms, and relying on the general prohibition of fraudulent conduct.
- Likely outside scope: Stablecoins and NFTs that are not crypto-assets under the Payment Services Act are described as having little need to be included, or as requiring careful consideration.
Impact on Markets and Companies
If crypto-assets come to be handled under the FIEA framework, exchange service providers are likely to face stronger disclosure, explanation and conduct requirements. For businesses considering raising funds through token issuance, the scope and method of disclosure would also become an important practical issue. Since investment advice, seminars and similar activities relating to crypto-assets may become regulated, operators of such businesses should pay attention to the eventual design of the rules. Hong Kong and other jurisdictions are also developing digital-asset regulation, and companies are likely to face more situations in which they must plan business with differences between Japanese and overseas regimes in mind.
Outlook and Schedule
Following the consultation, a "Working Group on the Crypto-Asset System" was established under the Financial System Council from July 2025 to deliberate on the specific design of the system. At the time the paper was published, the final content of the rules and the timing of any legislative amendments had not been decided.
Comment from TAKARA
The review of crypto-asset regulation is an important topic for businesses considering registration as a financial instruments business operator or as an investment advisory and agency business. TAKARA will continue to monitor regulatory developments and is available to assist with related licence application procedures.
Sources
This article provides general information based on published materials and news reports. It is not a solicitation or recommendation of any financial product and does not constitute investment advice.


