News
Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel sue the U.S. government to overturn the order blocking their merger
2025-01-06
Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel filed a petition in a U.S. federal appeals court, arguing that the prohibition order issued by President Biden on January 3 was unlawful political interference. The companies are also asking for a new review by CFIUS (the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States). The case has renewed attention on how large Japanese acquisitions in the U.S. interact with national security review.
Overview
On January 6, 2025 (U.S. time), Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel filed a petition with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. They asked the court to set aside the order President Biden issued on January 3 prohibiting Nippon Steel's acquisition of U.S. Steel. The companies argue that the order, and the review by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) behind it, were politically motivated and violated their due process and statutory rights. They want both the order and the CFIUS review set aside, and a new review conducted.
The all-cash deal priced U.S. Steel at $55 per share, for a total of about $14.9 billion (roughly $15 billion). The same day, the companies filed a separate lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The defendants are steelmaker Cleveland-Cliffs, its CEO Lourenco Goncalves, and David McCall, president of the United Steelworkers (USW) union.
Background
U.S. Steel accepted Nippon Steel's offer in 2023, having rejected an offer of about $7 billion from Cleveland-Cliffs. Nippon Steel had pledged to invest $2.7 billion in U.S. Steel's blast furnace operations in Gary, Indiana, and Pennsylvania's Mon Valley.
The deal went to CFIUS for review. In December 2024 the committee could not reach consensus on possible national security risks, which left the decision to the President. On January 3, 2025, President Biden prohibited the transaction under Section 721 of the Defense Production Act. The order required the parties to fully and permanently abandon the deal within 30 days unless CFIUS extended that deadline. According to press reports, it was the first time a U.S. president had blocked a merger between a U.S. company and a Japanese company.
Key Points
- Petition to the appeals court: The companies allege that the President and CFIUS violated their procedural and constitutional rights. They ask the court to set aside the order and the review and to require a new review.
- Fairness of the review: The companies claim the review was manipulated to support a conclusion the President had already reached. It was also reported that CFIUS had been told not to propose alternatives to the companies or hold discussions with them.
- Separate district court suit: The companies allege that Cleveland-Cliffs and USW leadership worked together to block the deal, citing anticompetitive and racketeering activities. The USW called the allegations baseless.
- Government position: The White House said a committee of national security and trade experts had determined that the deal would create risk.
Implications for Markets and Companies
A presidential order blocking an acquisition by a company from Japan, a close U.S. ally, on security grounds is likely to be seen as an important precedent by Japanese companies considering investment in the United States. In core industries such as steel, and in sectors with significant employment effects, it should be noted that the outcome of a CFIUS review may depend on political and labor considerations as well as on economic rationale.
For large cross-border M&A, the case is likely to reinforce the importance of planning early for regulatory review timelines, contractual arrangements if approval is not obtained, and engagement with local stakeholders. Companies from other regions, including mainland China and Hong Kong, will also need to assume a similar review environment when considering U.S. investments. In addition, resolving such disputes through litigation takes time, and it should be noted that uncertainty for the parties is likely to persist in the meantime.
Outlook and Schedule
By January 11, 2025, CFIUS had extended the deadline for abandoning the transaction to June 18, 2025, allowing time for the courts to consider the challenge. The companies filed their opening brief with the appeals court on February 3. President Trump, who took office on January 20, had said before his inauguration that he opposed the deal. At the time, how the review and the litigation would proceed under the new administration had not been determined.
Comment from TAKARA
This case shows that investment screening can decide the fate of a large overseas acquisition. TAKARA monitors developments in investment regulation and screening regimes in each jurisdiction and can provide information and procedural support for cross-border transactions.
Sources
This article provides general information based on published materials and news reports. It is not a solicitation or recommendation of any financial product and does not constitute investment advice.


